Not Sure Which Type of Tooth Filling to Choose?

Close-up of dentist performing tooth filling procedure in Sherwood Park

We help you compare white and metal fillings so you can make the best decision for your smile, health, and budget.

What You Need to Know About Tooth Fillings

Tooth fillings are one of the most common dental procedures—but for something so routine, there’s often a surprising amount of confusion around them.

When a dentist says you need a filling, it usually means there’s decay that needs to be removed, or a damaged tooth that requires structural support. What happens next depends on your individual needs, and one of the most common decisions you’ll face is: What type of filling should I get—composite or amalgam?

 

At Granada Dental in Sherwood Park, we help patients make that decision every day. Our job isn’t just to fix teeth—it’s to make sure you feel informed, confident, and comfortable throughout the entire process.

The Basics: Why a Filling Might Be Needed

Fillings serve one clear purpose: to repair and restore teeth that have been compromised. Whether it’s a cavity, a small chip, or an old filling that’s failing, this procedure can help you:

  • Stop the spread of decay

  • Prevent tooth sensitivity

  • Restore chewing strength

  • Avoid more complex treatments down the road

Fillings are a frontline solution for maintaining long-term oral health—and when caught early, the process is quick, conservative, and affordable.

Composite vs. Amalgam: What’s the Difference?

Let’s take a closer look at your two main choices.

Composite (White) Fillings

Made from a tooth-colored resin, these fillings blend seamlessly with your natural enamel. They’re a popular choice for patients who want an invisible repair.

Pros:

  • Matches your natural tooth shade

  • Bonds directly to the tooth surface

  • Ideal for front teeth or visible areas

  • Free of metal and mercury

Considerations:

  • More technique-sensitive

  • Slightly higher in cost

  • May wear slightly faster under heavy chewing pressure

Amalgam (Silver) Fillings

Made from a durable blend of metals, including silver, tin, copper, and mercury, these have been used for decades in dentistry.

Pros:

  • Very strong and long-lasting

  • Less expensive than composites

  • Great for molars and high-bite-pressure areas

Considerations:

  • Visible when you talk or smile

  • Contains mercury (in a stable, safe form)

  • Not recommended for patients with certain sensitivities
Illustration showing tooth decay, tooth filling procedure, and restored healthy tooth

So Which One Should You Choose?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer—but that’s exactly where Granada Dental comes in. We take a personalized approach that considers:

  • Where the tooth is located

  • How much chewing stress it handles

  • Your long-term aesthetic goals

  • Any medical conditions or sensitivities

  • Your insurance coverage and budget

     

If a front tooth has a small cavity, a white composite filling is likely the way to go. But if you’re repairing a back molar that does the heavy lifting when you eat, a strong silver amalgam may still be the best option.

Our role is to present the pros and cons clearly, explain the lifespan and look of each material, and help you weigh the trade-offs.

What About Safety?

Safety is a common concern—especially with amalgam fillings, which contain mercury. While major health organizations agree that amalgam fillings are stable and safe, we understand that many patients prefer to avoid them.

That’s why we also offer mercury-free composite materials for those seeking biocompatible, metal-free options. If you’re replacing an old silver filling, we follow safe removal protocols to minimize any exposure during the process.

You’ll always know exactly what’s going into your mouth, and why we recommend it.

What Does a Filling Appointment Look Like?

At Granada Dental, the experience is straightforward and stress-free:

  1. Numbing the area with local anesthetic for a pain-free visit

  2. Gently removing any decay or damaged material

  3. Cleaning and shaping the space to prepare for the filling

  4. Carefully placing the material and shaping it to match your bite

  5. Polishing and checking to ensure a comfortable finish

The whole process typically takes less than an hour—and in most cases, you can return to eating and speaking normally that same day.

How Long Will a Filling Last?

Fillings are durable, but not permanent. Their lifespan depends on the material, your oral habits, and the location of the tooth.

General estimates:

  • Composite: 5 to 10 years

  • Amalgam: 10 to 15 years or longer

To extend the life of your fillings, we recommend:

  • Brushing and flossing daily

  • Avoiding overly hard or sticky foods

  • Wearing a night guard if you grind your teeth

  • Coming in for regular checkups and cleanings

We’ll keep an eye on your dental work and let you know if anything needs maintenance or replacement.

Reception area at Granada Dental in Sherwood Park welcoming patients for tooth fillings

How Much Will It Cost?

Filling costs in Sherwood Park typically range between:

  • Composite fillings: $180–$300

  • Amalgam fillings: $120–$220

The final price depends on the size of the filling, the number of surfaces involved, and which tooth is being treated.

At Granada Dental, we:

  • Provide transparent cost estimates upfront

  • Offer direct billing to most insurance providers

  • Help you understand what’s covered under your plan

  • Never push for treatments you don’t need

We believe patients deserve clarity, not surprise bills. If you have coverage, we’ll do the legwork to get you the most from your plan.

Fillings for Children: A Calmer Experience for Parents Too

Cavities are common in kids—but early treatment helps protect developing teeth and avoid bigger issues later on. Our team works with children of all ages and creates a gentle, reassuring environment for first-time fillings.

We use child-friendly explanations, patience, and techniques to:

  • Keep the visit short and smooth

  • Offer options for white or stainless steel fillings

  • Answer your questions as a parent

  • Encourage positive feelings about going to the dentist

Most kids leave with a sticker—and no fear of coming back.

Nervous About Dental Visits? We’re Here to Help

If you’re feeling nervous or even a bit embarrassed about needing a filling, we get it—and we’ve built our practice around making dental care feel safe and respectful.

We offer:

  • Calming conversations before and during treatment

  • Sedation options (like nitrous oxide) if needed

  • A team that listens without judgment

  • A clean, modern, and friendly environment

We’ve helped many patients overcome long-time anxiety about the dentist, and we’re happy to help you too.

Why Choose Granada Dental for Fillings in Sherwood Park?

We’ve been serving Sherwood Park and surrounding areas for over 30 years—and we know what local families, professionals, and seniors value most:

  • Clear guidance on treatment options

  • Direct insurance billing

  • Convenient appointment times

  • A gentle, no-pressure experience

  • Filling materials tailored to your needs

Our patients come from Aspen Trails, Glen Allan, Heritage Hills, and Lakeland Ridge—and they stay because we treat them like people, not just procedures.

Ready to Get That Filling Taken Care Of?

If you’ve been delaying a dental visit or have questions about your options, we’re here to help. Whether it’s your first cavity or time to replace an old filling, Granada Dental makes it comfortable and clear from start to finish.